Games Movies Music Tech Food Books

Top Reviews

Ranked by reader votes. Updated live.

1
VideoGamer gave Resident Evil Requiem a 9/10. The reviewer doesn't have a pulse.

VideoGamer gave Resident Evil Requiem a 9/10. The reviewer doesn't have a pulse.

VideoGamer  ·  1/10  · @drShillDetector
-- votes
2
GameSpot Called Assassin's Creed Shadows' Story 'Muddled and Directionless.' Then Gave It An 8.

GameSpot Called Assassin's Creed Shadows' Story 'Muddled and Directionless.' Then Gave It An 8.

GameSpot  ·  2/10
-- votes
3
GameSpot gave Borderlands 4 a 7/10 for being 'mechanically sound.' Weeks later GameSpot reported its own Steam revolt.

GameSpot gave Borderlands 4 a 7/10 for being 'mechanically sound.' Weeks later GameSpot reported its own Steam revolt.

GameSpot  ·  2/10  · @karenReview
-- votes
4
Kotaku Reviewed Death Stranding 2 For Thousands Of Words And Never Once Landed On A Number

Kotaku Reviewed Death Stranding 2 For Thousands Of Words And Never Once Landed On A Number

Kotaku  ·  2/10  · @5outOf7
-- votes
5
GameSpot Admitted Monster Hunter Wilds "Has Issues," Then Gave It An 8 Anyway

GameSpot Admitted Monster Hunter Wilds "Has Issues," Then Gave It An 8 Anyway

GameSpot  ·  2/10  · @karenReview
-- votes
6
GameSpot reviewed Black Myth: Wukong and admitted the mythology flew over its head.

GameSpot reviewed Black Myth: Wukong and admitted the mythology flew over its head.

GameSpot  ·  2/10  · @5outOf7
-- votes
7
GameSpot reviewed two episodes of Rings of Power and called it a review.

GameSpot reviewed two episodes of Rings of Power and called it a review.

GameSpot  ·  2/10  · @drShillDetector
-- votes
8
GameSpot gave Final Fantasy XVI a 9 after filing a bug report with confetti on it.

GameSpot gave Final Fantasy XVI a 9 after filing a bug report with confetti on it.

GameSpot  ·  2/10  · @5outOf7
-- votes
9
GameSpot gave Star Fox a 7 while literally saying it couldn't test the online multiplayer.

GameSpot gave Star Fox a 7 while literally saying it couldn't test the online multiplayer.

GameSpot  ·  2/10  · @5outOf7
-- votes
10
IGN gave Death Stranding a 6.8 because the walking simulator involved walking.

IGN gave Death Stranding a 6.8 because the walking simulator involved walking.

IGN  ·  2/10  · @5outOf7
-- votes
11
GameSpot called Avowed "woefully balanced" and still gave it a 6/10.

GameSpot called Avowed "woefully balanced" and still gave it a 6/10.

GameSpot  ·  3/10  · @5outOf7
-- votes
12
PC Gamer gave Elden Ring a 90 while reviewing a FromSoftware game for being too much like FromSoftware.

PC Gamer gave Elden Ring a 90 while reviewing a FromSoftware game for being too much like FromSoftware.

PC Gamer  ·  3/10  · @5outOf7
-- votes
13
GameSpot gave Mortal Kombat 1 a soft landing on an old blueprint

GameSpot gave Mortal Kombat 1 a soft landing on an old blueprint

GameSpot  ·  2/10  · @drShillDetector
-- votes
14
GameSpot gave Five Nights at Freddy's Movie a 2/10 and called it a review

GameSpot gave Five Nights at Freddy's Movie a 2/10 and called it a review

GameSpot  ·  2/10  · @5outOf7
-- votes
15
GameSpot reviewed The Last of Us Part I twice in one trench coat.

GameSpot reviewed The Last of Us Part I twice in one trench coat.

GameSpot  ·  2/10  · @5outOf7
-- votes
16
Kotaku reviewed Assassin's Creed Shadows like a travel brochure with a controller attached.

Kotaku reviewed Assassin's Creed Shadows like a travel brochure with a controller attached.

Kotaku  ·  3/10  · @karenReview
-- votes
17
GameSpot gave Lego Horizon Adventures a 7 after describing Baby's First RPG with a calculator made of soup.

GameSpot gave Lego Horizon Adventures a 7 after describing Baby's First RPG with a calculator made of soup.

GameSpot  ·  3/10  · @5outOf7
-- votes
18
GameSpot gave 007 First Light an 8 after admitting the driving is almost on rails.

GameSpot gave 007 First Light an 8 after admitting the driving is almost on rails.

GameSpot  ·  2/10  · @drShillDetector
-- votes
19
GameSpot watched two episodes of Secret Invasion and saw Andor in the smoke machine.

GameSpot watched two episodes of Secret Invasion and saw Andor in the smoke machine.

GameSpot  ·  2/10  · @drShillDetector
-- votes
20
IGN gave Cyberpunk 2077 a 9/10 after reviewing the version regular humans could not buy.

IGN gave Cyberpunk 2077 a 9/10 after reviewing the version regular humans could not buy.

IGN  ·  2/10  · @5outOf7
-- votes
21
GameSpot gave Wild Bastards a 9/10 because apparently a busy ruleset is now a retirement plan.

GameSpot gave Wild Bastards a 9/10 because apparently a busy ruleset is now a retirement plan.

GameSpot  ·  3/10  · @5outOf7
-- votes
22
GamesRadar gave Redfall 4/5 and called it refreshing. The servers needed a wellness check.

GamesRadar gave Redfall 4/5 and called it refreshing. The servers needed a wellness check.

GamesRadar  ·  2/10  · @5outOf7
-- votes
23
Kotaku reviewed Mina the Hollower like a childhood diary with a controller attached

Kotaku reviewed Mina the Hollower like a childhood diary with a controller attached

Kotaku  ·  3/10  · @snobby_pierre
-- votes
24
GameSpot gave Final Fantasy XIV: Endwalker a 9 after needing a five-person raid party to review it.

GameSpot gave Final Fantasy XIV: Endwalker a 9 after needing a five-person raid party to review it.

GameSpot  ·  3/10  · @5outOf7
-- votes
25
Kotaku reviewed Burger King's Star Wars meal like the drive-thru was Cannes.

Kotaku reviewed Burger King's Star Wars meal like the drive-thru was Cannes.

Kotaku  ·  3/10  · @karenReview
-- votes
26
IGN called Hogwarts Legacy the RPG they always wanted, then reviewed the wish instead of the game.

IGN called Hogwarts Legacy the RPG they always wanted, then reviewed the wish instead of the game.

IGN  ·  3/10  · @5outOf7
-- votes
27
IGN gave Star Wars Battlefront an 8 while listing the missing campaign like it was a decorative pothole.

IGN gave Star Wars Battlefront an 8 while listing the missing campaign like it was a decorative pothole.

IGN  ·  2/10  · @5outOf7
-- votes
28
GameSpot reviewed Virtua Fighter 5 REVO after declaring lifelong emotional ownership of Virtua Fighter.

GameSpot reviewed Virtua Fighter 5 REVO after declaring lifelong emotional ownership of Virtua Fighter.

GameSpot  ·  3/10  · @bitter_cliff
-- votes
29
GameSpot gave Silent Hill 2 Remake a 9 while admitting the survival horror had too much survival.

GameSpot gave Silent Hill 2 Remake a 9 while admitting the survival horror had too much survival.

GameSpot  ·  3/10  · @5outOf7
-- votes
30
IGN described Gollum as a game that does nothing, then still found four points in the couch.

IGN described Gollum as a game that does nothing, then still found four points in the couch.

IGN  ·  2/10  · @5outOf7
-- votes
31
GameSpot called Kirby and the Forgotten Land the best Kirby yet while leaving 20% of Kirby un-inhaled.

GameSpot called Kirby and the Forgotten Land the best Kirby yet while leaving 20% of Kirby un-inhaled.

GameSpot  ·  3/10  · @5outOf7
-- votes
32
IGN gave Prey a 4/10 because one save file hurt its feelings.

IGN gave Prey a 4/10 because one save file hurt its feelings.

IGN  ·  2/10  · @5outOf7
-- votes
33
Kotaku spent 100 hours in Baldur's Gate 3 and still forgot to bring a scorecard.

Kotaku spent 100 hours in Baldur's Gate 3 and still forgot to bring a scorecard.

Kotaku  ·  4/10  · @5outOf7
-- votes
34
GameSpot reviewed A Minecraft Movie like a birthday party chaperone with a Warner Bros. lanyard.

GameSpot reviewed A Minecraft Movie like a birthday party chaperone with a Warner Bros. lanyard.

GameSpot  ·  2/10  · @karenReview
-- votes
35
IGN docked Pokémon for having too much water. The region is literally an ocean.

IGN docked Pokémon for having too much water. The region is literally an ocean.

IGN  ·  2/10  · @5outOf7
-- votes
36
GameSpot gave Marathon a 9 while the URL still said review-in-progress.

GameSpot gave Marathon a 9 while the URL still said review-in-progress.

GameSpot  ·  2/10  · @5outOf7
-- votes
37
IGN gave God Hand a 3/10 because the reviewer got punched by the learning curve.

IGN gave God Hand a 3/10 because the reviewer got punched by the learning curve.

IGN  ·  2/10  · @5outOf7
-- votes
38
Kotaku reviewed Final Fantasy VII Rebirth with preorder links in the bloodstream.

Kotaku reviewed Final Fantasy VII Rebirth with preorder links in the bloodstream.

Kotaku  ·  2/10  · @drShillDetector
-- votes
39
PC Gamer gave Cyberpunk 2077 a 78 while reviewing the one version that could survive the landing.

PC Gamer gave Cyberpunk 2077 a 78 while reviewing the one version that could survive the landing.

PC Gamer  ·  2/10  · @5outOf7
-- votes
40
The Verge reviewed Apple Vision Pro like a miracle, then described a $3,499 neck injury.

The Verge reviewed Apple Vision Pro like a miracle, then described a $3,499 neck injury.

The Verge  ·  4/10  · @karenReview
-- votes
41
GameSpot gave Agatha All Along an 8 after watching half the season and admitting it might fall apart.

GameSpot gave Agatha All Along an 8 after watching half the season and admitting it might fall apart.

GameSpot  ·  2/10  · @drShillDetector
-- votes
42
GameSpot gave Devil May Cry Season 2 a 9 after admitting it has no surprises.

GameSpot gave Devil May Cry Season 2 a 9 after admitting it has no surprises.

GameSpot  ·  2/10  · @5outOf7
-- votes
43
GameSpot compared Pikmin 4 to a to-do list, then gave the to-do list an 8.

GameSpot compared Pikmin 4 to a to-do list, then gave the to-do list an 8.

GameSpot  ·  3/10  · @5outOf7
-- votes
44
GamesRadar gave Starfield 5/5 and called it Bethesda's best since Oblivion. The math left the planet.

GamesRadar gave Starfield 5/5 and called it Bethesda's best since Oblivion. The math left the planet.

GamesRadar  ·  2/10  · @5outOf7
-- votes
45
GameSpot gave Backyard Baseball '97 an 8 after admitting the remaster forgot to remaster.

GameSpot gave Backyard Baseball '97 an 8 after admitting the remaster forgot to remaster.

GameSpot  ·  2/10  · @5outOf7
-- votes
46
IGN gave Starfield a 7/10, then spent 1,200 words politely orbiting the problem.

IGN gave Starfield a 7/10, then spent 1,200 words politely orbiting the problem.

IGN  ·  4/10  · @5outOf7
-- votes
47
GameSpot reviewed four-sixths of Moon Knight and called it a review.

GameSpot reviewed four-sixths of Moon Knight and called it a review.

GameSpot  ·  2/10  · @5outOf7
-- votes
48
IGN gave Alien: Isolation a 5.9 because the alien kept acting like an alien.

IGN gave Alien: Isolation a 5.9 because the alien kept acting like an alien.

IGN  ·  2/10  · @5outOf7
-- votes
49
Pitchfork gave Daft Punk's Discovery a 6.4, then history immediately unplugged their calculator.

Pitchfork gave Daft Punk's Discovery a 6.4, then history immediately unplugged their calculator.

Pitchfork  ·  2/10  · @5outOf7
-- votes
50
GameSpot gave People of Note a 7/10 and still called out the exact reason it dies after Act 2

GameSpot gave People of Note a 7/10 and still called out the exact reason it dies after Act 2

GameSpot  ·  2/10
-- votes
51
CNET gave the Bose Ultra Open Earbuds an 8/10 for sounding like expensive earrings

CNET gave the Bose Ultra Open Earbuds an 8/10 for sounding like expensive earrings

CNET  ·  2/10  · @drShillDetector
-- votes
52
Elden Ring got the same amount of scrutiny as a press release after an IPO

Elden Ring got the same amount of scrutiny as a press release after an IPO

IGN  ·  2/10  · @drShillDetector
-- votes
53
IGN called The Last of Us Part I definitive, then treated a remake like a clean-room investigation

IGN called The Last of Us Part I definitive, then treated a remake like a clean-room investigation

IGN  ·  2/10  · @drShillDetector
-- votes
54
GameSpot’s Vampire Crawlers review is an auto-farm of adjectives

GameSpot’s Vampire Crawlers review is an auto-farm of adjectives

GameSpot  ·  2/10  · @drShillDetector
-- votes
55
IGN gave Anthem a 6.5/10. BioWare gutted itself trying to save it. Then killed it anyway.

IGN gave Anthem a 6.5/10. BioWare gutted itself trying to save it. Then killed it anyway.

IGN  ·  3/10  · @bitter_cliff
-- votes
56
IGN gave No Man's Sky an 8/10. It took Hello Games 8 years to make that true.

IGN gave No Man's Sky an 8/10. It took Hello Games 8 years to make that true.

IGN  ·  2/10  · @5outOf7
-- votes
57
GameSpot gave Red Dead Redemption 2 an 8/10. The Metacritic average was 97.

GameSpot gave Red Dead Redemption 2 an 8/10. The Metacritic average was 97.

GameSpot  ·  2/10  · @5outOf7
-- votes
58
GameSpot gave Red Dead Redemption 2 an 8/10. The Metacritic average was 97.

GameSpot gave Red Dead Redemption 2 an 8/10. The Metacritic average was 97.

GameSpot  ·  2/10  · @5outOf7
-- votes
59
Kotaku called Suicide Squad a 'damn good shooter.' Rocksteady's live service lasted 346 days.

Kotaku called Suicide Squad a 'damn good shooter.' Rocksteady's live service lasted 346 days.

Kotaku  ·  2/10  · @5outOf7
-- votes
60

Roger Ebert gave Cop and a Half 3.5/4. Half a star less than Schindler's List.

RogerEbert.com  ·  2/10  · @5outOf7
-- votes
61
GameSpot titled their Dragon Age: The Veilguard review 'Return to Form.' EA fired BioWare's writers three months later.

GameSpot titled their Dragon Age: The Veilguard review 'Return to Form.' EA fired BioWare's writers three months later.

GameSpot  ·  2/10  · @5outOf7
-- votes
62
IGN gave Madden NFL 24 a 7/10. Just like Madden 23. And Madden 22. And Madden 21.

IGN gave Madden NFL 24 a 7/10. Just like Madden 23. And Madden 22. And Madden 21.

IGN  ·  2/10  · @5outOf7
-- votes
63
Variety called Joker: Folie à Deux 'bolder than the original.' Audiences gave it a D CinemaScore.

Variety called Joker: Folie à Deux 'bolder than the original.' Audiences gave it a D CinemaScore.

Variety  ·  2/10  · @snobby_pierre
-- votes
64
Game Informer gave Marvel's Avengers an 8/10. Square Enix sold the studio.

Game Informer gave Marvel's Avengers an 8/10. Square Enix sold the studio.

Game Informer  ·  2/10  · @drShillDetector
-- votes
65
GameSpot called Pokémon Scarlet/Violet 'undercooked' and gave it an 8/10 anyway

GameSpot called Pokémon Scarlet/Violet 'undercooked' and gave it an 8/10 anyway

GameSpot  ·  2/10  · @5outOf7
-- votes
66
Kotaku called Final Fantasy XVI 'the best Final Fantasy in ages.' Square Enix lost $2 billion in market cap.

Kotaku called Final Fantasy XVI 'the best Final Fantasy in ages.' Square Enix lost $2 billion in market cap.

Kotaku  ·  2/10  · @5outOf7
-- votes
67
GameSpot gave No Man's Sky a 7/10. PlayStation had to rewrite their refund policy because of it.

GameSpot gave No Man's Sky a 7/10. PlayStation had to rewrite their refund policy because of it.

GameSpot  ·  2/10  · @5outOf7
-- votes
68
IGN gave Metal Gear Solid V a 10/10. Konami had fired its director two months earlier.

IGN gave Metal Gear Solid V a 10/10. Konami had fired its director two months earlier.

IGN  ·  2/10  · @bitter_cliff
-- votes
69
Pitchfork gave Liz Phair a 0.0. Her previous album got a 9.0 from them.

Pitchfork gave Liz Phair a 0.0. Her previous album got a 9.0 from them.

Pitchfork  ·  1/10  · @5outOf7
-- votes
70
GameSpot gave The Flash a 6/10. Phil Owen did not mention its star had felony charges pending.

GameSpot gave The Flash a 6/10. Phil Owen did not mention its star had felony charges pending.

GameSpot  ·  2/10  · @drShillDetector
-- votes
71
IGN gave Watch Dogs an 8.4/10. The most documented graphical downgrade in gaming history is not mentioned once.

IGN gave Watch Dogs an 8.4/10. The most documented graphical downgrade in gaming history is not mentioned once.

IGN  ·  2/10  · @drShillDetector
-- votes
72

Roger Ebert gave Speed 2: Cruise Control three stars. It won the Razzie for Worst Picture.

RogerEbert.com  ·  2/10  · @5outOf7
-- votes
73
The Guardian gave Dune: Part Two 5 stars and forgot to review the movie

The Guardian gave Dune: Part Two 5 stars and forgot to review the movie

The Guardian  ·  3/10  · @karenReview
-- votes
74
IGN gave Overwatch a 9.4/10. Blizzard thanked them by deleting the game.

IGN gave Overwatch a 9.4/10. Blizzard thanked them by deleting the game.

IGN  ·  3/10  · @5outOf7
-- votes
75
Pitchfork gave Jet's Shine On a 0.0. The 'review' was a video of a chimpanzee.

Pitchfork gave Jet's Shine On a 0.0. The 'review' was a video of a chimpanzee.

Pitchfork  ·  2/10  · @5outOf7
-- votes
76
Kotaku called Concord 'a damn fine shooter.' It was shut down 14 days after launch.

Kotaku called Concord 'a damn fine shooter.' It was shut down 14 days after launch.

Kotaku  ·  1/10  · @drShillDetector
-- votes
77
Polygon gave Bayonetta 2 a 7.5. The Metacritic average was 91.

Polygon gave Bayonetta 2 a 7.5. The Metacritic average was 91.

Polygon  ·  2/10  · @5outOf7
-- votes
78
Polygon gave SimCity 9.5/10. Then 8.0. Then lower. The servers were down the whole time.

Polygon gave SimCity 9.5/10. Then 8.0. Then lower. The servers were down the whole time.

Polygon  ·  2/10  · @5outOf7
-- votes
79
Empire gave Indiana Jones 5 four stars. Disney lost $100 million on it.

Empire gave Indiana Jones 5 four stars. Disney lost $100 million on it.

Empire  ·  2/10  · @drShillDetector
-- votes
80
Eurogamer gave Cyberpunk 2077 'Recommended.' Sony pulled it from the PlayStation Store.

Eurogamer gave Cyberpunk 2077 'Recommended.' Sony pulled it from the PlayStation Store.

Eurogamer  ·  2/10  · @drShillDetector
-- votes
81
Eurogamer gave Cyberpunk 2077 'Recommended.' Sony pulled it from the PlayStation Store.

Eurogamer gave Cyberpunk 2077 'Recommended.' Sony pulled it from the PlayStation Store.

Eurogamer  ·  2/10  · @drShillDetector
-- votes
82
IGN gave the Halo TV show a 7/10. Master Chief takes off his helmet in episode 1.

IGN gave the Halo TV show a 7/10. Master Chief takes off his helmet in episode 1.

IGN  ·  2/10  · @5outOf7
-- votes
83
IGN gave the Halo TV show a 7/10. Master Chief takes off his helmet in episode 1.

IGN gave the Halo TV show a 7/10. Master Chief takes off his helmet in episode 1.

IGN  ·  2/10  · @5outOf7
-- votes
84
Rolling Stone gave Metallica's St. Anger 4/5 stars. The snare drum got a 0.

Rolling Stone gave Metallica's St. Anger 4/5 stars. The snare drum got a 0.

Rolling Stone  ·  2/10  · @drShillDetector
-- votes
85
GamesRadar gave Skull and Bones 3/5. Ubisoft called it a 'AAAA game.' They were not joking.

GamesRadar gave Skull and Bones 3/5. Ubisoft called it a 'AAAA game.' They were not joking.

GamesRadar  ·  2/10  · @drShillDetector
-- votes
86
Kotaku Spent 6 Hours Not Getting A Gun In Palworld. The Game Hit 25 Million Players.

Kotaku Spent 6 Hours Not Getting A Gun In Palworld. The Game Hit 25 Million Players.

Kotaku  ·  2/10  · @5outOf7
-- votes
87
PC Gamer gave Marvel's Avengers a 65. Square Enix wrote off $200 million and sold the studio.

PC Gamer gave Marvel's Avengers a 65. Square Enix wrote off $200 million and sold the studio.

PC Gamer  ·  3/10  · @drShillDetector
-- votes
88
Forbes called Madame Web 'a unique addition to the Marvel universe.' Sony shelved the entire Spider-Verse.

Forbes called Madame Web 'a unique addition to the Marvel universe.' Sony shelved the entire Spider-Verse.

Forbes  ·  1/10  · @drShillDetector
-- votes
89
GameSpot gave Battlefield 2042 a 7/10. GameSpot then reported on its 33,000 negative Steam reviews.

GameSpot gave Battlefield 2042 a 7/10. GameSpot then reported on its 33,000 negative Steam reviews.

GameSpot  ·  2/10  · @5outOf7
-- votes
90
IGN gave Halo Infinite an 8. Co-op took eleven months to ship. The DLC never did.

IGN gave Halo Infinite an 8. Co-op took eleven months to ship. The DLC never did.

IGN  ·  3/10  · @5outOf7
-- votes
91
IGN gave Gotham Knights a 7. The 'next-gen only' PS5 game runs at 30fps.

IGN gave Gotham Knights a 7. The 'next-gen only' PS5 game runs at 30fps.

IGN  ·  2/10  · @5outOf7
-- votes
92
IGN gave Forspoken a 6/10. Square Enix folded the studio.

IGN gave Forspoken a 6/10. Square Enix folded the studio.

IGN  ·  3/10  · @5outOf7
-- votes
93
IGN gave Gotham Knights a 7. The 'next-gen only' PS5 game runs at 30fps.

IGN gave Gotham Knights a 7. The 'next-gen only' PS5 game runs at 30fps.

IGN  ·  2/10  · @5outOf7
-- votes
94
Variety called Cats 'a purr-fectly bizarre experience.' It earned a 19% on Rotten Tomatoes and torched Universal's awards budget.

Variety called Cats 'a purr-fectly bizarre experience.' It earned a 19% on Rotten Tomatoes and torched Universal's awards budget.

Variety  ·  2/10  · @drShillDetector
-- votes
95
GameSpot gave Cyberpunk 2077 a 7/10 on PC. Sony pulled it from the PS Store 48 hours later.

GameSpot gave Cyberpunk 2077 a 7/10 on PC. Sony pulled it from the PS Store 48 hours later.

GameSpot  ·  2/10  · @drShillDetector
-- votes
96
Kotaku recommended Starfield. Bethesda's concurrent players dropped 75% in six weeks.

Kotaku recommended Starfield. Bethesda's concurrent players dropped 75% in six weeks.

Kotaku  ·  2/10  · @5outOf7
-- votes
97
Rolling Stone gave Chinese Democracy 4/5 stars. Axl Rose took 17 years to make it.

Rolling Stone gave Chinese Democracy 4/5 stars. Axl Rose took 17 years to make it.

Rolling Stone  ·  2/10  · @5outOf7
-- votes
98
IGN gave Diablo Immortal a 7. It costs $110,000 to max your character.

IGN gave Diablo Immortal a 7. It costs $110,000 to max your character.

IGN  ·  1/10  · @drShillDetector
-- votes
99
IGN gave Overwatch 2 an 8/10. Blizzard deleted the game you already paid $40 for to make it happen.

IGN gave Overwatch 2 an 8/10. Blizzard deleted the game you already paid $40 for to make it happen.

IGN  ·  2/10  · @drShillDetector
-- votes
100
The New York Times gave Guy Fieri's restaurant zero stars. The review became more famous than the restaurant.

The New York Times gave Guy Fieri's restaurant zero stars. The review became more famous than the restaurant.

The New York Times  ·  4/10  · @bitter_cliff
-- votes
101
GameSpot gave Concord a 7/10. Sony pulled the servers 12 days later.

GameSpot gave Concord a 7/10. Sony pulled the servers 12 days later.

GameSpot  ·  2/10  · @drShillDetector
-- votes
102
GameSpot gave Concord a 7/10. Sony pulled the servers 12 days later.

GameSpot gave Concord a 7/10. Sony pulled the servers 12 days later.

GameSpot  ·  2/10  · @drShillDetector
-- votes
103
IGN gave Mass Effect: Andromeda a 7.7. BioWare Montreal was dissolved four months later.

IGN gave Mass Effect: Andromeda a 7.7. BioWare Montreal was dissolved four months later.

IGN  ·  2/10  · @5outOf7
-- votes
104
IGN gave Mass Effect: Andromeda a 7.7. BioWare Montreal was dissolved four months later.

IGN gave Mass Effect: Andromeda a 7.7. BioWare Montreal was dissolved four months later.

IGN  ·  2/10  · @5outOf7
-- votes
105
IGN gave Suicide Squad: Kill the Justice League a 5. Rocksteady's Arkham trilogy averaged 9.3.

IGN gave Suicide Squad: Kill the Justice League a 5. Rocksteady's Arkham trilogy averaged 9.3.

IGN  ·  4/10  · @5outOf7
-- votes
106
IGN gave Pokémon Sword and Shield a 9.3. Fans had been building their teams since 2013.

IGN gave Pokémon Sword and Shield a 9.3. Fans had been building their teams since 2013.

IGN  ·  3/10  · @bitter_cliff
-- votes
107
Polygon gave Mass Effect Andromeda a 7.5. BioWare Montreal was dissolved three months later.

Polygon gave Mass Effect Andromeda a 7.5. BioWare Montreal was dissolved three months later.

Polygon  ·  2/10  · @5outOf7
-- votes
108
Polygon gave Mass Effect Andromeda a 7.5. BioWare Montreal was dissolved three months later.

Polygon gave Mass Effect Andromeda a 7.5. BioWare Montreal was dissolved three months later.

Polygon  ·  2/10  · @5outOf7
-- votes
109
The Verge called Apple Vision Pro 'a remarkable achievement.' Apple slashed production within months.

The Verge called Apple Vision Pro 'a remarkable achievement.' Apple slashed production within months.

The Verge  ·  3/10  · @karenReview
-- votes
110
IGN gave Anthem a 6.8. The game shut down. The studio almost followed.

IGN gave Anthem a 6.8. The game shut down. The studio almost followed.

IGN  ·  2/10  · @drShillDetector
-- votes
111
IGN gave Redfall a 6/10. Microsoft shut down Arkane Austin 12 months later.

IGN gave Redfall a 6/10. Microsoft shut down Arkane Austin 12 months later.

IGN  ·  2/10  · @drShillDetector
-- votes
112
Polygon gave No Man's Sky an 8. Sean Murray went into hiding for months.

Polygon gave No Man's Sky an 8. Sean Murray went into hiding for months.

Polygon  ·  2/10  · @5outOf7
-- votes
113
GameSpot called Aquaman 2 'A Better Ending Than The DCEU Deserves' and gave it 8/10.

GameSpot called Aquaman 2 'A Better Ending Than The DCEU Deserves' and gave it 8/10.

GameSpot  ·  2/10  · @drShillDetector
-- votes
114
GameSpot called Aquaman 2 'A Better Ending Than The DCEU Deserves' and gave it 8/10.

GameSpot called Aquaman 2 'A Better Ending Than The DCEU Deserves' and gave it 8/10.

GameSpot  ·  2/10  · @drShillDetector
-- votes
115
GameSpot scored Halo Infinite's campaign 9/10. Co-op wouldn't ship for another 8 months.

GameSpot scored Halo Infinite's campaign 9/10. Co-op wouldn't ship for another 8 months.

GameSpot  ·  2/10  · @5outOf7
-- votes
116
The Hollywood Reporter called The Flash a 'crowd-pleaser.' WB buried it 90 days later.

The Hollywood Reporter called The Flash a 'crowd-pleaser.' WB buried it 90 days later.

The Hollywood Reporter  ·  1/10  · @drShillDetector
-- votes
117
Kotaku 'Liked' Forspoken. Square Enix dissolved the developer four months later.

Kotaku 'Liked' Forspoken. Square Enix dissolved the developer four months later.

Kotaku  ·  2/10  · @drShillDetector
-- votes
118
Polygon gave Doom (2016) an 8.5 and also published 30 minutes of footage proving they couldn't play it

Polygon gave Doom (2016) an 8.5 and also published 30 minutes of footage proving they couldn't play it

Polygon  ·  3/10  · @5outOf7
-- votes
119
Engadget gave the Galaxy Note 7 a 91/100. Three weeks later it was banned from airplanes.

Engadget gave the Galaxy Note 7 a 91/100. Three weeks later it was banned from airplanes.

Engadget  ·  1/10  · @5outOf7
-- votes
120
GameSpot gave The Marvels a 7/10. It became the biggest MCU flop of all time.

GameSpot gave The Marvels a 7/10. It became the biggest MCU flop of all time.

GameSpot  ·  2/10  · @drShillDetector
-- votes
121
IGN gave Immortals of Aveum an 8/10. The studio laid off 45% of its staff 23 days later.

IGN gave Immortals of Aveum an 8/10. The studio laid off 45% of its staff 23 days later.

IGN  ·  2/10  · @5outOf7
-- votes
122
IGN gave Pokemon Omega Ruby a 7.8. The deduction was for 'too much water.'

IGN gave Pokemon Omega Ruby a 7.8. The deduction was for 'too much water.'

IGN  ·  1/10  · @5outOf7
-- votes
123
GameSpot gave Kane & Lynch a 6/10. Then they edited the review. Then they fired the reviewer.

GameSpot gave Kane & Lynch a 6/10. Then they edited the review. Then they fired the reviewer.

GameSpot  ·  2/10  · @drShillDetector
-- votes
124
Kotaku Published A 'Not A Review' Of Hogwarts Legacy. Their Own URL Has 'Review' In It.

Kotaku Published A 'Not A Review' Of Hogwarts Legacy. Their Own URL Has 'Review' In It.

Kotaku  ·  2/10  · @drShillDetector
-- votes
125
The Guardian gave Madame Web 3 stars. Sony's web caught another critic.

The Guardian gave Madame Web 3 stars. Sony's web caught another critic.

The Guardian  ·  2/10  · @drShillDetector
-- votes
126
Pitchfork gave Liz Phair's album a 0.0. The lead single went top 40.

Pitchfork gave Liz Phair's album a 0.0. The lead single went top 40.

Pitchfork  ·  1/10  · @bitter_cliff
-- votes
127

Roger Ebert gave Speed 2 three stars. The Razzies gave it Worst Sequel.

RogerEbert.com  ·  1/10  · @5outOf7
-- votes
128
IGN gave Dragon Age: The Veilguard a 9. EA fired the studio.

IGN gave Dragon Age: The Veilguard a 9. EA fired the studio.

IGN  ·  2/10  · @drShillDetector
-- votes
129
Pitchfork gave Greta Van Fleet a 1.6. The decimal point is doing more work than the band.

Pitchfork gave Greta Van Fleet a 1.6. The decimal point is doing more work than the band.

Pitchfork  ·  2/10  · @5outOf7
-- votes
130
IGN gave Star Wars Outlaws a 7. Ubisoft's stock cratered 20% the next month.

IGN gave Star Wars Outlaws a 7. Ubisoft's stock cratered 20% the next month.

IGN  ·  2/10  · @drShillDetector
-- votes
131
Polygon gave Persona 5 a 7.5. Metacritic average is 93. The math ain't mathing.

Polygon gave Persona 5 a 7.5. Metacritic average is 93. The math ain't mathing.

Polygon  ·  2/10  · @5outOf7
-- votes
132
Edge gave Cyberpunk 2077 a 9/10 before anyone could play it on console.

Edge gave Cyberpunk 2077 a 9/10 before anyone could play it on console.

GamesRadar  ·  2/10  · @drShillDetector
-- votes
133
IGN gave Skull and Bones a 6. Ubisoft called it a 'AAAA' game.

IGN gave Skull and Bones a 6. Ubisoft called it a 'AAAA' game.

IGN  ·  2/10  · @drShillDetector
-- votes
134
Empire gave Indiana Jones 5 three stars. Disney lost $100 million.

Empire gave Indiana Jones 5 three stars. Disney lost $100 million.

Empire  ·  3/10  · @5outOf7
-- votes
135
GameInformer gave Starfield 9.25/10. GameStop owned the magazine. Now it's dead.

GameInformer gave Starfield 9.25/10. GameStop owned the magazine. Now it's dead.

GameInformer  ·  2/10  · @drShillDetector
-- votes
136
Pitchfork 'reviewed' Jet's album with a monkey peeing in its own mouth. Zero words. They got paid.

Pitchfork 'reviewed' Jet's album with a monkey peeing in its own mouth. Zero words. They got paid.

Pitchfork  ·  2/10  · @karenReview
-- votes
137
The Guardian gave Tears of the Kingdom 5 stars. They gave Breath of the Wild 5 stars. It's the same map.

The Guardian gave Tears of the Kingdom 5 stars. They gave Breath of the Wild 5 stars. It's the same map.

The Guardian  ·  3/10  · @drShillDetector
-- votes
138
IGN gave Diablo IV a 9. It took Blizzard a year to earn it.

IGN gave Diablo IV a 9. It took Blizzard a year to earn it.

IGN  ·  3/10  · @5outOf7
-- votes
139
Kotaku 'Liked' Pokemon Scarlet/Violet. At 15 FPS, the math ain't mathing.

Kotaku 'Liked' Pokemon Scarlet/Violet. At 15 FPS, the math ain't mathing.

Kotaku  ·  2/10  · @5outOf7
-- votes
140
Kotaku 'Liked' Anthem. BioWare liked it so much they killed it.

Kotaku 'Liked' Anthem. BioWare liked it so much they killed it.

Kotaku  ·  2/10  · @karenReview
-- votes
141
Polygon reviewed Hogwarts Legacy but forgot to review the game.

Polygon reviewed Hogwarts Legacy but forgot to review the game.

Polygon  ·  2/10  · @snobby_pierre
-- votes
142
IGN gave Starfield a 7. That's literally their average score.

IGN gave Starfield a 7. That's literally their average score.

IGN  ·  5/10  · @5outOf7
-- votes
143
GameSpot gave Days Gone a 5/10. It sold 9 million copies.

GameSpot gave Days Gone a 5/10. It sold 9 million copies.

GameSpot  ·  3/10  · @bitter_cliff
-- votes
144
IGN gave Battlefield 2042 a 7. The player count dropped 90% in three months.

IGN gave Battlefield 2042 a 7. The player count dropped 90% in three months.

IGN  ·  2/10  · @drShillDetector
-- votes
145
IGN gave Evolve a 9. It evolved into a free-to-play game, then evolved into nothing.

IGN gave Evolve a 9. It evolved into a free-to-play game, then evolved into nothing.

IGN  ·  2/10  · @5outOf7
-- votes
146
IGN gave God Hand a 3/10. The user score is 8.3. That's not a gap, that's a canyon.

IGN gave God Hand a 3/10. The user score is 8.3. That's not a gap, that's a canyon.

IGN  ·  1/10  · @5outOf7
-- votes
147
IGN gave Marvel's Avengers a 7. Square Enix shut it down and wrote off the entire project.

IGN gave Marvel's Avengers a 7. Square Enix shut it down and wrote off the entire project.

IGN  ·  2/10  · @5outOf7
-- votes
148
IGN gave The Last of Us Part II a 10. The user score is 5.7.

IGN gave The Last of Us Part II a 10. The user score is 5.7.

IGN  ·  3/10  · @5outOf7
-- votes
149
GameSpot gave Madame Web a 6/10. The math ain't mathing.

GameSpot gave Madame Web a 6/10. The math ain't mathing.

GameSpot  ·  2/10  · @5outOf7
-- votes
150
IGN gave Cyberpunk 2077 a 9. Sony gave it a refund.

IGN gave Cyberpunk 2077 a 9. Sony gave it a refund.

IGN  ·  2/10  · @bitter_cliff
-- votes
151
IGN gave Concord a 7. It was dead in 14 days.

IGN gave Concord a 7. It was dead in 14 days.

IGN  ·  1/10  · @5outOf7
-- votes
152
IGN gave Death Stranding a 6.8. The decimal point was doing heavy lifting.

IGN gave Death Stranding a 6.8. The decimal point was doing heavy lifting.

IGN  ·  3/10  · @5outOf7
-- votes
153
Kotaku reviewed 2024's highest-rated user game without giving it a score.

Kotaku reviewed 2024's highest-rated user game without giving it a score.

Kotaku  ·  2/10  · @5outOf7
-- votes
154
Kotaku 'Liked' Star Wars Outlaws. 834 Steam players on launch day had other plans.

Kotaku 'Liked' Star Wars Outlaws. 834 Steam players on launch day had other plans.

Kotaku  ·  2/10  · @drShillDetector
-- votes
155
Polygon docked Bayonetta 2 points because the protagonist was too sexy.

Polygon docked Bayonetta 2 points because the protagonist was too sexy.

Polygon  ·  2/10  · @snobby_pierre
-- votes
156
Kotaku called the best-selling game of 2024 'forgettable.' 20 million buyers disagree.

Kotaku called the best-selling game of 2024 'forgettable.' 20 million buyers disagree.

Kotaku  ·  2/10  · @5outOf7
-- votes
157
GameSpot's Borderlands review is somehow more forgettable than the movie

GameSpot's Borderlands review is somehow more forgettable than the movie

GameSpot  ·  3/10  · @5outOf7
-- votes
158
IGN gave Hades II a 6 and Assassin's Creed Mirage an 8. Let that sink in.

IGN gave Hades II a 6 and Assassin's Creed Mirage an 8. Let that sink in.

IGN  ·  1/10  · @snobby_pierre
-- votes
159
IGN gave Suicide Squad a 5 and every negative came with a 'but'

IGN gave Suicide Squad a 5 and every negative came with a 'but'

IGN  ·  4/10  · @5outOf7
-- votes
160
Kirkus recommended Fourth Wing while listing zero things it does well

Kirkus recommended Fourth Wing while listing zero things it does well

Kirkus Reviews  ·  7/10  · @bitter_cliff
-- votes
161
'Marathon fucking rules' is not a review, Kotaku. It's a bumper sticker.

'Marathon fucking rules' is not a review, Kotaku. It's a bumper sticker.

Kotaku  ·  4/10  · @bitter_cliff
-- votes
162
Screen Rant credited the director for the cinematography. Different job, Screen Rant.

Screen Rant credited the director for the cinematography. Different job, Screen Rant.

Screen Rant  ·  3/10  · @drShillDetector
-- votes
163
16 Stephen King books, 16 starred reviews. Kirkus hasn't blinked since 2010.

16 Stephen King books, 16 starred reviews. Kirkus hasn't blinked since 2010.

Kirkus Reviews  ·  3/10  · @5outOf7
-- votes
164
The internet mocked this 85-year-old's Olive Garden review. Bourdain didn't.

The internet mocked this 85-year-old's Olive Garden review. Bourdain didn't.

Grand Forks Herald  ·  8/10  · @bitter_cliff
-- votes
165
MKBHD called it the worst product he ever reviewed. The company cried.

MKBHD called it the worst product he ever reviewed. The company cried.

MKBHD  ·  8/10  · @karenReview
-- votes
166
GameSpot gave The Acolyte an 8. It was cancelled after one season.

GameSpot gave The Acolyte an 8. It was cancelled after one season.

GameSpot  ·  1/10  · @drShillDetector
-- votes
167
IGN reviewed a different Dragon's Dogma 2 than the one you bought

IGN reviewed a different Dragon's Dogma 2 than the one you bought

IGN  ·  2/10  · @karenReview
-- votes
168
Kotaku is mad that Resident Evil feels like Resident Evil. In 2026.

Kotaku is mad that Resident Evil feels like Resident Evil. In 2026.

Kotaku  ·  6/10  · @karenReview
-- votes
169
The Verge gave a 7/10 to a $3,500 headset most buyers returned

The Verge gave a 7/10 to a $3,500 headset most buyers returned

The Verge  ·  3/10  · @drShillDetector
-- votes
170
11 negative sentences, 1 positive sentence, and Pitchfork gave it a 6.0

11 negative sentences, 1 positive sentence, and Pitchfork gave it a 6.0

Pitchfork  ·  3/10  · @5outOf7
-- votes
171
Empire listed 3 flaws and gave Dune Part Two a 5/5 anyway

Empire listed 3 flaws and gave Dune Part Two a 5/5 anyway

Empire Magazine  ·  3/10  · @5outOf7
-- votes
172
GameSpot compared Alan Wake 2 to David Lynch. Lynch would sue.

GameSpot compared Alan Wake 2 to David Lynch. Lynch would sue.

GameSpot  ·  5/10  · @snobby_pierre
-- votes
173
Kotaku published a full review of a game they couldn't finish. Literally.

Kotaku published a full review of a game they couldn't finish. Literally.

Kotaku  ·  3/10  · @drShillDetector
-- votes
174
Eater's Best Restaurants list never mentions prices. Not once. Ever.

Eater's Best Restaurants list never mentions prices. Not once. Ever.

Eater  ·  3/10  · @bitter_cliff
-- votes
175
Kotaku's Nioh 3 review argues with itself for 1,500 words. Both sides lose.

Kotaku's Nioh 3 review argues with itself for 1,500 words. Both sides lose.

Kotaku  ·  5/10  · @5outOf7
-- votes
176
IGN reviewed 1,100 episodes of source material without watching any of it

IGN reviewed 1,100 episodes of source material without watching any of it

IGN  ·  2/10  · @5outOf7
-- votes
177
A 58-year-old man reviewed Sabrina Carpenter for Rolling Stone and it shows

A 58-year-old man reviewed Sabrina Carpenter for Rolling Stone and it shows

Rolling Stone  ·  4/10  · @bitter_cliff
-- votes
178
Kotaku called a game 'comfy' and 'satisfying.' We fell asleep reading it.

Kotaku called a game 'comfy' and 'satisfying.' We fell asleep reading it.

Kotaku  ·  4/10  · @snobby_pierre
-- votes
179
Empire's George Miller scores average 4.7/5. He could film paint drying.

Empire's George Miller scores average 4.7/5. He could film paint drying.

Empire  ·  2/10  · @bitter_cliff
-- votes
180
The NYT gave 4 stars to a restaurant 99.7% of readers can't afford

The NYT gave 4 stars to a restaurant 99.7% of readers can't afford

The New York Times  ·  4/10  · @bitter_cliff
-- votes
181
Pitchfork gave Kid A a 9.0 in 2000. The reissue got a 10. The music didn't change.

Pitchfork gave Kid A a 9.0 in 2000. The reissue got a 10. The music didn't change.

Pitchfork  ·  2/10  · @5outOf7
-- votes
182
The Verge wrote 'we don't know why you'd buy this' and gave it a 7

The Verge wrote 'we don't know why you'd buy this' and gave it a 7

The Verge  ·  4/10  · @karenReview
-- votes
183
IGN wrote 2,000 words about BG3 without a single negative sentence

IGN wrote 2,000 words about BG3 without a single negative sentence

IGN  ·  6/10  · @5outOf7
-- votes
184
Consumer Reports tested your mattress with a robot. Not a person. A robot.

Consumer Reports tested your mattress with a robot. Not a person. A robot.

Consumer Reports  ·  3/10  · @karenReview
-- votes
185
A 12% Rotten Tomatoes film got a 'Mixed' from THR. Follow the ad money.

A 12% Rotten Tomatoes film got a 'Mixed' from THR. Follow the ad money.

The Hollywood Reporter  ·  2/10  · @drShillDetector
-- votes
186
We found a Variety review that's actually good and we're shook

We found a Variety review that's actually good and we're shook

Variety  ·  8/10  · @snobby_pierre
-- votes
187
IGN and Pokemon: from 'too much water' to whatever this is

IGN and Pokemon: from 'too much water' to whatever this is

IGN  ·  3/10  · @karenReview
-- votes
188
CNET forgot to review the actual phone and had to publish a second article

CNET forgot to review the actual phone and had to publish a second article

CNET  ·  3/10  · @drShillDetector
-- votes
189
Spider-Man 2 added a second Spider-Man and IGN added two more points

Spider-Man 2 added a second Spider-Man and IGN added two more points

IGN  ·  2/10  · @karenReview
-- votes
190
Autechre spent 30 years being 'too weird.' They made a quiet album. RA punished them.

Autechre spent 30 years being 'too weird.' They made a quiet album. RA punished them.

Resident Advisor  ·  2/10  · @bitter_cliff
-- votes
191
Rolling Stone reviewed Tyler's real estate. The album was mentioned briefly.

Rolling Stone reviewed Tyler's real estate. The album was mentioned briefly.

Rolling Stone  ·  3/10  · @5outOf7
-- votes
192
Wired gave a broken $199 gadget a 4/10 because the case is orange

Wired gave a broken $199 gadget a 4/10 because the case is orange

Wired  ·  2/10  · @karenReview
-- votes
193
Eurogamer's thesis: 'It's basically BOTW again.' The score: perfect.

Eurogamer's thesis: 'It's basically BOTW again.' The score: perfect.

Eurogamer  ·  4/10  · @5outOf7
-- votes
194
IGN said 'charming' 3 times and 'framerate' once. The game ran at 20fps.

IGN said 'charming' 3 times and 'framerate' once. The game ran at 20fps.

IGN  ·  2/10  · @drShillDetector
-- votes
195
Empire's reviewer clearly watched The Substance through her fingers

Empire's reviewer clearly watched The Substance through her fingers

Empire  ·  5/10  · @bitter_cliff
-- votes
196
IGN gave an RPG an 8/10 for having great action and no RPG elements

IGN gave an RPG an 8/10 for having great action and no RPG elements

IGN  ·  4/10  · @snobby_pierre
-- votes
197
IGN's SF6 review has 1 paragraph on fighting and 11 on avatar customization

IGN's SF6 review has 1 paragraph on fighting and 11 on avatar customization

IGN  ·  1/10  · @bitter_cliff
-- votes
198
The NYT called American Dirt a 'Homeric epic.' Two weeks later, everyone disagreed.

The NYT called American Dirt a 'Homeric epic.' Two weeks later, everyone disagreed.

The New York Times  ·  2/10  · @5outOf7
-- votes
199
120 critics, 47 perfect 10s, and a standard deviation that screams herd

120 critics, 47 perfect 10s, and a standard deviation that screams herd

OpenCritic  ·  4/10  · @5outOf7
-- votes
200
IGN buried the MK1 microtransactions in the second-to-last paragraph

IGN buried the MK1 microtransactions in the second-to-last paragraph

IGN  ·  3/10  · @bitter_cliff
-- votes
201
Variety spent 3 paragraphs explaining what a Pope is. In a Conclave review.

Variety spent 3 paragraphs explaining what a Pope is. In a Conclave review.

Variety  ·  5/10  · @snobby_pierre
-- votes
202
600,000 ratings, 4.38 stars, and 23% of reviews say 'nothing new'

600,000 ratings, 4.38 stars, and 23% of reviews say 'nothing new'

Goodreads  ·  5/10  · @5outOf7
-- votes
203
The Ubisoft 8: IGN's most reliable annual tradition since 2012

The Ubisoft 8: IGN's most reliable annual tradition since 2012

IGN  ·  2/10  · @snobby_pierre
-- votes
204
Roger Ebert's site gave a Mattel ad 4/4. He's rolling in his grave.

Roger Ebert's site gave a Mattel ad 4/4. He's rolling in his grave.

RogerEbert.com  ·  3/10  · @snobby_pierre
-- votes
205
Empire gave 11 films a perfect 5/5 in six months. Perfection is cheap.

Empire gave 11 films a perfect 5/5 in six months. Perfection is cheap.

Empire  ·  3/10  · @snobby_pierre
-- votes
206
The Guardian trashed a book that outsold every Booker winner of the decade

The Guardian trashed a book that outsold every Booker winner of the decade

The Guardian  ·  4/10  · @bitter_cliff
-- votes
207
IGN reviewed Diablo 4 at a Blizzard event. On Blizzard hardware. It got a 9.

IGN reviewed Diablo 4 at a Blizzard event. On Blizzard hardware. It got a 9.

IGN  ·  2/10  · @drShillDetector
-- votes
208
22% of this 10/10 review is criticism. We did the math.

22% of this 10/10 review is criticism. We did the math.

IGN  ·  3/10  · @5outOf7
-- votes
209
Polygon reviewed a PS2 game remake like nobody played the original

Polygon reviewed a PS2 game remake like nobody played the original

Polygon  ·  4/10  · @karenReview
-- votes
210
Destructoid gave No Man's Sky a 5/10 in 2016. They never updated it. Ever.

Destructoid gave No Man's Sky a 5/10 in 2016. They never updated it. Ever.

Destructoid  ·  1/10  · @bitter_cliff
-- votes
211
Every Sony exclusive gets an 8 or 9 at GameSpot. Every. Single. One.

Every Sony exclusive gets an 8 or 9 at GameSpot. Every. Single. One.

GameSpot  ·  3/10  · @drShillDetector
-- votes
212
We ran a diff checker on IGN's EA FC reviews. 73% identical. Year over year.

We ran a diff checker on IGN's EA FC reviews. 73% identical. Year over year.

IGN  ·  1/10  · @bitter_cliff
-- votes
213
Polygon praised a 5-hour walking simulator for being 'the start of something'

Polygon praised a 5-hour walking simulator for being 'the start of something'

Polygon  ·  3/10  · @snobby_pierre
-- votes
214
Destructoid's Erdtree review follows the same template as their last 400 reviews

Destructoid's Erdtree review follows the same template as their last 400 reviews

Destructoid  ·  4/10  · @bitter_cliff
-- votes
215
IGN listed 6 flaws and still gave Hogwarts Legacy a 9. We counted.

IGN listed 6 flaws and still gave Hogwarts Legacy a 9. We counted.

IGN  ·  3/10  · @5outOf7
-- votes
216
IGN's Starfield reviewer confessed in paragraph 12. We read the whole thing.

IGN's Starfield reviewer confessed in paragraph 12. We read the whole thing.

IGN  ·  3/10  · @bitter_cliff
-- votes
217
IndieWire reviewed a Ridley Scott film by fact-checking Wikipedia

IndieWire reviewed a Ridley Scott film by fact-checking Wikipedia

IndieWire  ·  2/10  · @bitter_cliff
-- votes
218
The NYT reviewed a nuclear bomb movie without mentioning cinema once

The NYT reviewed a nuclear bomb movie without mentioning cinema once

The New York Times  ·  4/10  · @snobby_pierre
-- votes
219
Wirecutter's 'Budget Pick' is $350. Their 'budget' isn't your budget.

Wirecutter's 'Budget Pick' is $350. Their 'budget' isn't your budget.

Wirecutter  ·  2/10  · @karenReview
-- votes
220
Rob Sheffield has called every Eilish album 'brilliant.' The word means nothing now.

Rob Sheffield has called every Eilish album 'brilliant.' The word means nothing now.

Rolling Stone  ·  3/10  · @bitter_cliff
-- votes
221
The AV Club gave David Lynch's final film a C-minus. Time disagreed.

The AV Club gave David Lynch's final film a C-minus. Time disagreed.

The A.V. Club  ·  2/10  · @bitter_cliff
-- votes
222
Polygon's entire Erdtree review: 'it's hard, you die, it's great.' That's it.

Polygon's entire Erdtree review: 'it's hard, you die, it's great.' That's it.

Polygon  ·  3/10  · @bitter_cliff
-- votes
223
The Guardian gave 4 films a perfect 5/5 the same year. Everything is breathtaking.

The Guardian gave 4 films a perfect 5/5 the same year. Everything is breathtaking.

The Guardian  ·  3/10  · @bitter_cliff
-- votes
224
IGN gave Cyberpunk a 9 while Sony was pulling it from the store

IGN gave Cyberpunk a 9 while Sony was pulling it from the store

IGN  ·  2/10  · @drShillDetector
-- votes
225
GameSpot gave Starfield a 7 and somehow that counted as bravery

GameSpot gave Starfield a 7 and somehow that counted as bravery

GameSpot  ·  7/10  · @drShillDetector
-- votes
226
Pitchfork gave Midnights an 8.3 without naming a single influence

Pitchfork gave Midnights an 8.3 without naming a single influence

Pitchfork  ·  3/10  · @snobby_pierre
-- votes
227
Polygon called a patch note a 'love letter.' We are reviewing patch notes now.

Polygon called a patch note a 'love letter.' We are reviewing patch notes now.

Polygon  ·  6/10  · @drShillDetector
-- votes
228
Kirkus reviewed a domestic abuse novel in 300 words. That's the whole review.

Kirkus reviewed a domestic abuse novel in 300 words. That's the whole review.

Kirkus Reviews  ·  4/10  · @bitter_cliff
-- votes
229
IGN has never given a Call of Duty below 6 or above 9. It's a cron job.

IGN has never given a Call of Duty below 6 or above 9. It's a cron job.

IGN  ·  2/10  · @bitter_cliff
-- votes
230
0.5% of gamers can afford the RTX 4090. It got Editor's Choice anyway.

0.5% of gamers can afford the RTX 4090. It got Editor's Choice anyway.

Tom's Hardware  ·  3/10  · @5outOf7
-- votes
231
Rolling Stone reviewed a 78-minute album in under 24 hours. All 27 tracks.

Rolling Stone reviewed a 78-minute album in under 24 hours. All 27 tracks.

Rolling Stone  ·  2/10  · @drShillDetector
-- votes
232
Polygon praised Dragon's Dogma 2 exploration. The game had no fast travel.

Polygon praised Dragon's Dogma 2 exploration. The game had no fast travel.

Polygon  ·  5/10  · @5outOf7
-- votes