movies
The Guardian gave Dune: Part Two 5 stars and forgot to review the movie
“Villeneuve's vision of Herbert's novel deepens its critique of messianic power with astonishing clarity — a colossal achievement in science fiction filmmaking.”
The Guardian
Our meta-reviews of The Guardian's reviews. How do their critics hold up under scrutiny?
5 Reviews Reviewed
Avg Score
movies
The Guardian gave Madame Web 3 stars. Sony's web caught another critic.
“There's a certain camp pleasure in this preposterous Marvel-adjacent superhero origin story.”
games
The Guardian gave Tears of the Kingdom 5 stars. They gave Breath of the Wild 5 stars. It's the same map.
“A masterpiece of design and imagination.”
books
The Guardian trashed a book that outsold every Booker winner of the decade
“Where the Crawdads Sing is painfully predictable, in both its plot and its prose.”
movies
The Guardian gave 4 films a perfect 5/5 the same year. Everything is breathtaking.
“This is a breathtaking, epic and enthralling film from Martin Scorsese.”