Games Movies Music Tech Food Books
Screenshot of GameSpot's movies review: GameSpot gave The Flash a 6/10. Phil Owen did not mention its star had felony charges pending.

GameSpot gave The Flash a 6/10. Phil Owen did not mention its star had felony charges pending.

· Reviewing GameSpot
← All Reviews
2
out of 10 Our score for this review

The Original Review

GameSpot — Phil Owen
Rated: 6/10 · Published:
“DC doing a fun, Back to the Future-style time travel adventure is a great idea.”

Let's establish the media ecosystem. Warner Bros. Discovery — the studio behind The Flash — is one of the largest entertainment advertisers in the gaming media space. Fandom Inc., which acquired GameSpot from Red Ventures in late 2022, hosts DC content, DC advertising, and DC-affiliated sponsored placements across its properties. Phil Owen's review of The Flash lands on embargo day, June 7, 2023, handing the film a 6/10. These facts exist independently. Whether they relate is left as an exercise for the reader.

Here is what Phil Owen wrote about: the Back to the Future-style time travel plot, Michael Keaton's return as Batman, the chemistry between the two Barrys, and the third-act CGI he found lacking. Here is what Phil Owen did not write about: Ezra Miller's two arrests in Hawaii in 2022 (assault, disorderly conduct), the felony burglary charges pending in Vermont for which Miller would plead no contest in October 2023, the grooming and harassment allegations that dominated entertainment news for months, or the fact that Warner Bros. executives held crisis meetings debating whether to release the film at all. Zero sentences on any of this. Not even a boilerplate 'this review evaluates the film on its cinematic merits' disclaimer. Just: a Back to the Future-style time travel adventure is a great idea.

Here is the math. The Flash cost approximately $220 million to produce and another $100–150 million to market. It grossed $108 million worldwide — a combined loss of roughly $260 million, making it one of the costliest superhero disasters in studio history. Warner Bros. subsequently cancelled or rebooted every DC film in development. The entire DC Extended Universe — thirteen films, a decade of storytelling, the careers of everyone who built it — was handed to James Gunn to restart from scratch. Phil Owen called this movie 'a decent and quite fun time travel adventure.' A $260 million crater that ended a cinematic universe is not an adventure. That is an extinction event.

The 6/10 is the most precisely calibrated number in the review. Not low enough to suppress opening weekend attendance. Not high enough to look like it was filed from Warner Bros.' PR wing. The Goldilocks score of embargo-day publishing: just the right temperature to ensure nobody gets hurt — nobody at the studio, anyway. The star's arrest record was not hurt. The advertising relationship between WBD and Fandom properties was not hurt. The only casualty was any audience member who trusted that a professional review would tell them the full story. Sponsored by the truth.

#embargo-day#missing-context#corporate-friendly#box-office-bomb#dc-disaster
Was this review of a review fair?
Dr. Shill Detector — Follows the money
@drShillDetector Follows the money “Sponsored by the truth.”