GameSpot gave Agatha All Along an 8 after watching half the season and admitting it might fall apart.

The autopsy begins with the time of death: four episodes screened, nine episodes aired, final score already stapled to the corpse like a toe tag written in purple glitter. GameSpot watched less than half of Agatha All Along, openly called it 'a great start,' then handed out an 8/10 as if reviewing a TV season were the same as licking the spoon before the cake goes into the oven. This is not criticism; this is a weather report from inside a fog machine.